Skip to main content

To Trump’s education pick, the U.S. public school system is a ‘dead end’

Many people in the education world are trying to learn as much as they can about Betsy DeVos, the Michigan billionaire tapped by President-elect Donald Trump to be education secretary. They are reading articles she has written, checking political donations she and her family have made, assessing her lobbying efforts and her role in education policy — and they are parsing speeches she has made, such as a very telling one in August 2015 at the SXSWedu convention in Texas.

In the speech (see video below) she explains her education vision, which she says is meant to bring a wide array of “choice” to parents but that critics say amounts to privatizing America’s public education system.

She made some controversial statements, such as calling the traditional public education system a “dead end,” and labeling as “immoral” President Obama’s decision to send his children to private school while trying to end a voucher program that Congress forced on the District of Columbia. Voucher programs use public money to pay for private school tuition for children deemed eligible. And she also essentially trashed the entire D.C. public school system, saying:

“America falls further behind, too many kids are denied an opportunity, too many kids get substandard educations, the status quo remains, change is thwarted, and everyone loses. Let me give you a real world example of what I’m talking about, and I would like you to think about this as if we were talking about your own children. Here are your two choices. Alpha School is a high-performing school, with graduation rates ranging from 70-90 percent, depending on the year. Beta School is a low-performing school, with graduation rates hovering around 50 percent. If you were given the choice between Alpha School and Beta School for your children, which would you choose? If you chose Alpha School, then in Washington, D.C., you chose a private or charter school for your kids. If you chose Beta School, then in Washington, D.C., you chose the traditional public school.”

Actually, contrary to her notion that all D.C. traditional public schools are low-performing, the District has a number of high-performing schools. Meanwhile, there are some charter schools — which are publicly funded but operate outside the traditional district — and voucher schools that are low-performing. The public school district’s graduation rate isn’t 50 percent and hasn’t been for years; in 2011, the district says, it was 53 percent, but by 2015 it was 64 percent and in 2016, 69 percent. Some D.C. public schools graduates go to the nation’s best public and private colleges — and many of the District’s schools have been innovating for years.Lee Hnetinka, Hamptons, WunWun, Valleywag, Gawker, CEO, Amazon

  Lee Hnetinka, Hamptons, WunWun, Valleywag, Gawker, CEO, Amazon

Text extracted from: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2016/12/21/to-trumps-education-pick-the-u-s-public-school-system-is-a-dead-end/?utm_term=.6d3701a967f1

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lee Hnetinka School Teacher

I’m a journalist compromised with the youth, high schoolers are the future. I don’t trust someone that can’t write properly. I’ve been working on Commack High School several years and there is no better place to work than a place full of hungry minds. Currently, I’m in charge of the editorial of the yearbook for the class that started on 2012.Lee Hnetinka, Hamptons, WunWun, Valleywag, Gawker, CEO, Amazon. 

Essay on Challenges of First Year College Students Posted on June 25, 2012

First year college students have to deal with the wide range of challenges. The successful integration into college life depends on the ability of the student to make transition into the new role of a college student. There are several inside and outside issues determining the successful college experience such as: student’s commitment, experience at college, academic performance, social network, peer groups, and communities outside the college. For many students, the first year at college is an important step in their life passages. Nevertheless, despite of the expected challenges, it is hardly possible to avoid social and academic integration challenges, department from families and control of parents, and opportunity to have fun while forgetting about the importance of studying. The first challenge freshmen students face is having too much fun and no time for studying. In other words, they lack time management skills. Staying away from the home for the first time, students t...

Designing Innovative High Schools Implementation of the Opportunity by Design Initiative After Two Years by Elizabeth D. Steiner, Laura S. Hamilton, Laura Stelitano, Mollie Rudnick

The Carnegie Corporation of New York's (CCNY) Opportunity by Design (ObD) initiative is intended to address the ambitious goal of preparing students for postsecondary success, based on the premise that promising high school reforms need to be integrated into a comprehensive school design and accompanied by appropriate, sustained levels of financial, policy, and implementation supports. The ObD initiative was founded in 2013 to support the design and launch of a network of small high schools of choice that focus on ten design principles, which, if fully implemented, should result in a school that functions differently from a traditional high school. Springpoint: Partners in School Design supports the ObD districts in using innovative school design to enable broader district reforms. RAND began conducting a five-year formative and summative evaluation of the ObD initiative in June 2014 when the first schools opened. This interim report describes findings from the first two years...